18545 Rutledge Road sold twice in a little over a year. It has a 1951 house of 1,025 square feet, one and a quarter stories, three bedrooms and a detached garage, on a quarter-acre lot. It sold for $625,000 in January 2025 and for $650,000 on February 2, 2026. Hennepin County's appraiser added one line to the second sale: "Home purchased by Gonyea for future build."
The buyer was paying for the lot, and Rutledge Road isn't the only case. On Deephaven's streets back from Lake Minnetonka, older houses sell at land prices, and newer houses a few blocks away sell for several times as much. The town's headline median sits between those two levels. Which of the two sold more often in a given year moves that median more than any change in what a particular house is worth.
The assessor's 2026 sales book, published in the City of Deephaven's April 6, 2026 council packet, groups several recent sales under a heading called "Land and Redevelopment." Here they are side by side:
| Address | Sale date | Net sale price | Lot size | Appraiser's note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3610 Northome Ave. | April 28, 2025 | $360,000 | 6,098 sq. ft. | House demolished for new build, land sale, then listed for $495,000 |
| 18540 Azure Rd. | June 20, 2025 | $400,000 | 10,890 sq. ft. | Purchased to demolish structure and rebuild |
| 18545 Rutledge Rd. | Feb. 2, 2026 | $650,000 | 10,890 sq. ft. | Purchased by Gonyea for future build |
| 19110 Lake Ave. | Jan. 15, 2025 | $675,000 | Not listed here | Purchased to demolish the old home and rebuild |
None of these has lake frontage on its record, and every one sold for land value. Per square foot of lot, they cover a wide range. Northome Avenue sold for about $59 a square foot of land. Azure Road sold for about $37. Rutledge Road sold for about $60, with the house still standing at the time of sale. After the house at 3610 Northome came down, the cleared 0.14-acre lot was listed at $495,000, about $81 a square foot.
Rutledge Road also shows how land prices moved over that stretch. The house sold for $625,000 in January 2025 and for $650,000 a year later, about 4% more, for a 1951 house of about 1,000 square feet.
The Azure Road sale shows the whole cycle. The lot sold for $400,000 in June 2025, and the assessor's 2026 record lists a 2025-built, one-and-a-half-story house of 1,535 square feet above grade with three bedrooms and a detached garage. By the fall of 2026 the new house was finished. It's a modest house, so a rebuild on these streets doesn't always mean a large one.
The same sales book shows where a finished house ends up. 18600 Highland Avenue, built in 2021, sold for $1,600,000 on April 15, 2025. It has 3,804 square feet above grade on a 20,038-square-foot lot with no lake frontage. 3525 Montgomerie Avenue, built in 2023, sold for $1,890,000 on June 2, 2025. It has 3,882 square feet above grade on a lot of the same 20,038 square feet, also off the water.
Put the two sets of sales together. In 2025, an off-lake Deephaven lot with an older house on it sold for somewhere between the high $300,000s and the high $600,000s. A newer house of about 3,800 square feet on a lot of about 20,000 square feet sold for $1.6 million to $1.9 million. Two buyers on the same street can be shopping at very different prices, depending on whether the house is older or new.
Lakeshore is a market of its own. 19720 Lakeview Avenue, built in 2020 with 107 effective feet of Lake Minnetonka frontage, sold for $5,260,100 on January 8, 2025. Shoreline brings its own questions, which we've covered in our piece on Lake Minnetonka lake easements. This post is about the streets behind it.
Minneapolis Area REALTORS' Deephaven Local Market Update for October 2026 shows 46 closed sales in the 12 months ending October 2026 and a median sale price of $1,300,000. A year earlier, the 12-month median was $1,015,000, so the gain is 28.1%. Over the same 12 months, price per square foot rose 11.9% to $425, sellers received 93.0% of their original list price, and homes took 70 days on average to sell.
The county's numbers move much less. For the 2026 assessment, Hennepin County put Deephaven's median single-family estimated market value at $1,017,300, up from $999,450 the year before. The city assessor's summary put single-family market growth at 1.5% once new construction is taken out.
The assessor revalues every house in town. The REALTORS median covers whichever 46 houses happened to sell. In a city this size, a few new or nearly new houses selling in the same year can raise the median far more than they raise the value of the 1950s ranch next door. The county counted 15 new single-family houses in Deephaven in 2023, 5 in 2024 and 8 in 2025. That's a small number of houses, but enough to move a median built on fewer than 50 sales.
October by itself had just three closings, a $1,700,000 median and 264 days on market. The report itself warns that a single month "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." Inventory at the end of October was 20 homes, or 5.2 months of supply, down from 23 homes and 6.2 months a year earlier.
If you're looking at an older house on an off-lake Deephaven street, check the lot size and the year the house was built before the kitchen photos. The 2025 and 2026 land sales above show what buyers paid when they wanted the lot more than the house, and some of those buyers were buying for a future build. A quarter-acre lot with a 1950s house sold for $400,000 on Azure Road and for $650,000 on Rutledge Road. Those two sales tell you more about where your offer lands than the town's $1.3 million median.
If you're looking at a newer house, compare it with the newer sales. The 2021 and 2023 houses on Highland and Montgomerie each have about 3,800 square feet above grade on a 20,038-square-foot lot, and they're the reference points for that part of the market. A 12-month median that mixes both kinds of sale says little about either one.
If you own an older house here and are thinking about selling, the assessor's notes show two kinds of buyers. Some want the house as it stands. Others buy for a future build, and the two groups value the same property differently. A home valuation that looks only at the house can miss the land sales nearby. Our Deephaven neighborhood page and buyer's guide cover the rest of what goes into a Lake Minnetonka search.
Is every older Deephaven house a teardown? No. The November 17, 2026 Planning Commission agenda had one public hearing, for an addition to a 1958 house on Montgomerie Avenue. Owners renovate and add on too.
Do teardown lots in Deephaven sit on the lake? None of the four land sales in the assessor's 2026 book lists lake frontage. The lakeshore sale on Lakeview Avenue brought more than $5 million.
Which market number should I trust? For a town with 46 sales a year, use the 12-month figures and treat any single month with caution. MAAR's October report makes the same point.
If you're wondering whether a 1950s Deephaven house will sell as a home or as a lot, or what to offer on one, we'd love to look at the sales near your street with you. Schedule a Free Consultation with Nicole Stone Real Estate, and bring the address.
We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!